News

Circuit Breakers Comparison: Guide to MCB, RCCB, and RCBO Differences

March 19, 2024
Products Images Contacts
Circuit Breakers Comparison: Guide to MCB, RCCB, and RCBO Differences-0

In the world of electrical installations, circuit breakers play a very important role in ensuring the safety of the overall electrical network. There are basically three types of circuit breakers, which are most commonly used not only in the industrial sector but also in households and offices. Circuit-breakers, popularly known as automated circuit-breakers, are divided into several intelligent types, the characteristics of which determine the most suitable niche for the application.

Table of contents:

 

How work circuit breakers

A circuit breaker, often referred to as a fuse, breaker or plug, is a special component designed to protect your electrical system. When an overload or leakage is detected, it switches off the electricity supply to the internal circuit, thus protecting both users from accidents and equipment from damage. The first slot was described by Thomas Edison in 1879. However, the circuit breaker as we know it today was patented in 1924. The patent was filed by the Swiss company Brown, Boveri & Cie. Within 100 years, its use and efficiency had been improved.

Two main operating principles of circuit breakers:

  1. Thermal protection. Stops current flow if a special bimetallic strip made of two different metals gets too hot. As each metal has a different expansion capability, it bends when heated and triggers a circuit-breaking mechanism or "popping the caps". Such circuit-breakers are suitable for households and their main purpose is to prevent overloading, for example when several powerful appliances are connected to the mains and switched on at the same time. Also, in the event of a short circuit, the power will be cut off.
  2. Electromagnetic protection. This principle is based on the properties of a steep magnetic field. It is particularly effective in the event of a surge current. As the current rises above a certain level, the electromagnetic force increases, which accordingly triggers the opening mechanism, separating the contacts and disconnecting the circuit.

 

Trip classes or sensitivity of circuit breakers

tripping curvesThe non-working class of circuit breakers, sometimes referred to as sensitivity, is divided according to their response to overload and short-circuit currents to ensure adequate protection for electrical installations. In other words, this class determines how quickly the circuit breaker will react when disconnecting the power supply to protect the electrical equipment from damage.

Type B circuit breakers

Type B circuit breakers are among the most common and are predominantly found in households. They are suitable for situations where the starting current of the equipment is not too high, such as lighting and socket circuits. They provide de-energisation after 3 to 5 times the rated current. This intelligently protects electrical equipment from damage and even fires.

Type C circuit breakers

Type C circuit breakers are required in areas where the current surge is moderate, such as commercial premises or light industry. They are often used with electric motors and in fluorescent lamp circuits where starting current surges are common. When the current rises 5-10 times the rated value, these circuit breakers detect this as an overload and disconnect the current.

Type D circuit breakers

Type D circuit breakers are an important component of electro-automation in heavy industry where very high starting currents are encountered, such as large electric motors and powerful workbenches. They react to overcurrents and disconnect them when they are 10 to 20 times the rated value. This ensures safety and protects equipment from damage.

Type Z circuit breakers

Type Z circuit breakers protect highly sensitive electronic equipment such as computer power supplies, various medical equipment, electronic sensors and other sensitive devices where fast response and precise overload control are important. They are designed to respond to very small overloads - below 2 times the rated current.

Type K circuit breakers

Type K circuit breakers are used in industrial applications where power consumption is very high and additional protection against overcurrent is required. They are found in the energy sector where they ensure the stability of the power supply and protect systems against overloads, for example in power plants and power monitoring systems. In addition, they are used in industrial automation systems where high reliability and stability are required, such as production lines and industrial robots. In these industries, Type K circuit breakers can ensure the safety of electrical equipment, even in high current situations, helping to prevent accidents and maintain system stability. Their response to overcurrent is 8 to 12 times the rated amperage, which ensures system stability and safety.

Type Industies Triping time Example
B Type Households, offices 3-5 times the rated current Lighting, outlet circuits, appliances with low starting current
Type Workspaces, light industry, small worktables 5-10 times the rated current Electric motors, fluorescent lamps, and other devices with increased starting current
Type Heavy industry, high-power machinery 10-20 times the rated current Large electric motors, equipment with very high starting current
Type Industries with sensitive electronics, for which a fast response to disconnection is important less than 2 times the rated current Computer power supplies, sensitive electronics
Type Industries with very powerful equipment that has high starting current surges and requires additional safety 8-12 times the rated current Large electric motors, X-ray equipment, compressors

 

Each class of circuit breaker is designed for specific conditions and solutions to ensure optimum protection and efficiency in electrical installations. When selecting a circuit breaker, it is important to consider both current and potential future needs.

 

MCB: Modular circuit breakers

The classic MCB (Miniature Circuit Breaker) is a common component in electrical installations that serves as a switch that opens an electrical circuit when excessive current flows through it. Unlike fuses, MCBs can be re-energized after tripping, thus improving safety and control. They are often used as an alternative to fuse switches in a variety of settings, from domestic to industrial. MCB circuit breakers come in different types and have different tripping characteristics to suit specific applications.

When selecting an MCB for a specific application, factors such as rated current, breaking capacity and MCB type must be taken into account to ensure safe protection against overloads and short-circuits. Correct selection is essential to prevent frequent tripping or inadequate protection of connected loads and equipment.

MCB specification

Type: A, B, C, D, H, K, Z
Current: 0.5A - 125A
Tripping: <2 - 20 times of nominal
Poles: 1P - 4P
Load capacity: 4.5kA - 25kA
Voltage: to 400V

Top MCB circuit breakers

A9F73120 20A 1P Schneider Electric
View

BM618116 16A 1P Schrack Technik
View

BM618106 6A 1P Schrack Technik
View

BM618332 32A 3P Schrack Technik
View

 

RCCB: Leakage circuit breakers

Residual current circuit breakers (RCCBs) are devices that are not very common, but are becoming more and more sought after because of their critical role in the context of electrical safety. Unlike modular circuit breakers, which react to overloads, RCCBs monitor power losses in the network. This means that if current starts to flow away uncontrolled, for example through a person or a faulty wire, these machines react immediately, preventing a potentially dangerous situation and protecting life and property. Such machines are very important because they provide an extra level of electrical safety, which is vital in various electrical installations and industrial environments where safety is a priority.

RCCB specification

Class: A, AC, B
Current: 16A - 125A
Tripping: 6kA - 10kA
Poles: 1P - 4P
Sensitivity: 10mA - 1000mA
Voltage: to 440V

Top RCCB circuit breakers

AR054103 40A 4P Schrack Technik
View

A9R41263 63A 2P Schneider Electric
View

A9R21425 25A 4P Schneider Electric
View

AR056203 63A 3P Schrack Technik
View

 

RCBO: Residual current circuit breakers

rcbo circute brakersCombined circuit breakers (RCBOs) are an essential component of electrical networks, combining two important types of circuit breakers - modular and leakage. This device is able to react to both overvoltage and blackouts, thus providing pallet protection against potentially dangerous power failures.

The combination circuit breaker acts as a protection device to ensure safety against power failures and to prevent power leakage during temporary faults in the electrical system. It is particularly common in electrical networks subject to high loads and requiring robust and reliable protection.

A major advantage of the combined circuit breaker is that both surge and leakage protection functions are contained in a single module. This not only reduces the number of switches in the switchgear rows, but also simplifies and makes the maintenance and management of the power supply systems more efficient.

RCBO specification

Type: B, C, D
Current: 2A - 40A
Tripping: 6kA - 10kA
Poles: 1P - 4P
Sensitivity: 30mA - 100mA
Voltage: to 400V

Top RCBO circuit breakers

A9D31616 16A 2P Schneider Electric
View

BO668816 16A 4P Schrack Technik
View

AK667606 6A 2P Schrack Technik
View

A9D20610 10A 2P Schneider Electric
View

Comparison of MCB, RCCB and RCBO circuit breakers

Parameters MCB RCCB RCBO
Current 6A - 63A 16A - 100A 6A - 63A
Voltage 240/415V (AC) 240/415V (AC) 240/415V (AC)
Standstill speed range 2.5 ms (short circuit), 2s - 2 min (overload) < 30ms < 30ms
Usage Electrical installations, equipment protection Electrical installations, leakage protection Combined surge and leakage protection
Tripping sensitivity Not specifically defined, depends on type 6mA, 10mA, 30mA, 50mA, 100mA 6mA, 10mA, 30mA, 50mA, 100mA
Tripping speed 2.5 ms - 2 min (depends on congestion) < 30ms < 30ms
Poles Usually single or 2-pole Usually 2-pole or 4-pole Usually single or 2-pole

 

Looking at the three types, each has its own unique advantages and applications. The MCB is generic and broadly applicable, providing protection against overloads and short circuits, while the RCBO offers combined protection against both overvoltages and leakage currents. RCBs, on the other hand, although less common, are extremely important as they can quickly prevent potentially dangerous power leakages that could cause serious damage to life and property. In summary, the correct choice of circuit breaker is essential to ensure the reliability and safety of electrical systems, whether for domestic or industrial applications.

Products
A9F73120
Code: A9F73120
In stock: 5+ pcs In stock: 0 (on request)
5.93 EUR (w/o VAT)
BM617106
Code: BM617106
In stock: 5+ pcs In stock: 0 (on request)
3.85 EUR (w/o VAT)
BM617306
Code: BM617306
In stock: 5+ pcs In stock: 0 (on request)
13.09 EUR (w/o VAT)
AR054103
Code: AR054103
In stock: 5+ pcs In stock: 0 (on request)
27.58 EUR (w/o VAT)
A9R21440
Code: A9R21440
In stock: 4 pcs In stock: 0 (on request)
68.38 EUR (w/o VAT)
BO668816
Code: BO668816
In stock: 4 pcs In stock: 0 (on request)
91.63 EUR (w/o VAT)
Contact the manager
Mārtiņš Kāns
Mārtiņš Kāns
Project Division Manager
+371 2910 0172
martins@lasma.eu
Images